College versus the NBA
I tweeted about this quite a bit a few minutes ago, but thought it was worth blogging about. Jay Bilas and Dick Vitale have been calling for high school basketball players, once they sign with colleges, to have to stay in college for three years before entering the draft. That’s the same system they have for the NFL and, to a certain extent, college baseball though in baseball you can go into the draft out of high school, but once you get to college, you have to be 21 before you enter the draft. The difference between playing pro football out of high school and playing pro basketball and baseball is pretty significant. But i’m going to concentrate on football and basketball for now. For every Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, Kevin Garnett and Dwight Howard there are very few high school football players who can go straight to the NFL because they’re just not ready physically. Bo Jackson, Herschel Walker and maybe even Marcus Lattimore were exceptions. But there are just not many of those, very few, maybe a half to one percent.
In basketball, it’s more realistic. You don’t have to have reached your potential physically in basketball to make the jump to the NBA. Guys like James and Howard were already pretty developed and could make the jump. Bryant and Garnett needed to grow, but they had the skill level to make it to the league. So in basketball, there are exceptions, not a lot, but some, who can make the leap from high school to the pros. It’s against the rules because kids have to spend one year in college basketball to qualify for the NBA draft.
But disallowing a player to make the jump after a year is unconstitutional. Don’t get me wrong, I love college basketball. I want to see guys stay as long as possible so the quality of play is better. There is a huge difference between a junior and senior and a freshman and even a sophomore though there are the exceptions there; the elite guys. Just think if John Wall, DeMarcus Cousins and Eric Bledsoe had come back to Kentucky. They would have been awesome this year. But John Calipari has to keep reloading with new freshmen every year it’s starting to seem like.
But you can’t deny a guy his right to play professionally and earn a living. That seems to be a violation of his freedom of speech in my opinion. There are commentators like Skip Bayless of ESPN who think the kids should be allowed to play professionally right out of high school, and, constitutionally, they are probably right. But everybody wants the level of play to be better in college and in pro ball. Kids going out of high school and being able to play in the NBA are more frequent now, but not that frequent. It doesn’t matter because the rule is one year of college ball as decided by the NBA and the NCAA. That could be challenged in the future, but that’s the way it is right now.
I think two years in college ball makes sense. Players get a chance to develop their skills, maybe help their team win a national championship and become more mature people emotionally and physically.
I still believe in the college game and think it’s terrific, but I can’t deny a young guys’ right to make a living. College basketball is really a business for these guys. And while I’m a strong believer in getting an education, a lot of these guys don’t want to be in school; they just want to play basketball. They deserve that right. Really, legally, the right thing to do is to let them go straight to the NBA out of high school. But I don’t think the league or college basketball wants that. It might ruin the quality of play at both levels. Players should be paid a stipend in college as I have called for in previous blogs, to give them incentive to want to attend and play college basketball. I think that should happen in the future. But for right now, I think it should be a two year tenure in college for guys who want to play in the NBA. I can’t argue with one year, the way it is now; but in my opinion, two years would be more beneficial for all parties, the NBA, the NCAA and the players. Also, for the fans.
(LeBron and Kobe made the jump from high school to the NBA successfully.)